What It’s Like to Be a College Soccer Player at a Small School vs. a Big University

Choosing the right college soccer program involves more than just the level of competition. One major factor to consider is the size and type of the school. Playing at a large university is a different experience from playing at a smaller college—but both can offer incredible opportunities for student-athletes.

In this blog, we’ll break down the key differences between soccer life at big universities and small schools across the U.S., covering everything from facilities and academics to team culture and exposure—so you can make an informed decision that fits your goals.

Training Facilities and Resources

At large universities (especially NCAA Division I), facilities tend to be state-of-the-art. These programs often have:

• Dedicated locker rooms and team meeting spaces
• Full-time strength and conditioning staff
• Sports science support (GPS tracking, heart rate monitors, etc.)
• On-campus stadiums with fan attendance and media coverage

In contrast, smaller schools (NAIA, NCAA D2, D3, or junior colleges) may not have the same budget or space, but still offer excellent training environments. Many small colleges:

• Provide high-quality fields and gyms
• Offer more personal access to staff
• Focus on efficiency and flexibility in training schedules

While the scale differs, both environments can support player development if the coaching is strong and the program is well organized.

Level of Competition and Style of Play

Generally, bigger schools compete at higher athletic levels, especially in Division I. The pace of play is faster, players tend to be more physically developed, and roster depth is greater. You may find international players, future professionals, and national team athletes on the same field.

Smaller schools may play at a slightly slower pace, but the level is still highly competitive. In fact, many NAIA and Division II programs regularly beat D1 teams in friendlies. You’ll also find technically skilled players, high-performing academics, and driven student-athletes across all levels.

The key difference is often the depth of talent and day-to-day competition within the roster, not necessarily the quality of top players.

Academics and Class Size

One of the biggest differences lies in the classroom.

At large universities, class sizes (especially for underclassmen) can be big—sometimes hundreds of students. While academic resources are extensive, students may need to be more proactive to seek help or stand out.

At small schools, classes are typically much smaller, with easier access to professors and advisors. This can be a great fit for students who prefer more one-on-one support or value close academic mentorship.

Balancing soccer and academics is essential no matter the school size. If you're preparing for this transition, don’t miss our article on How to Prepare for Your First Year as a College Soccer Player.

Game Day Atmosphere and Fan Support

Big universities often bring larger crowds, student sections, and more media attention—especially for major matchups and conference play. Some programs even have televised games and strong alumni support.

Smaller schools, while more intimate, often have passionate local followings. Games may feel more community-driven and personal, with family, professors, and peers cheering from the sidelines.

Both environments offer exciting game-day experiences—whether you're playing in a stadium with 5,000 fans or on a packed local field with classmates right at the fence.

Coach-to-Player Interaction

At smaller schools, players often enjoy closer relationships with their coaches. With smaller rosters and tighter-knit athletic departments, communication can be more frequent and personalized.

At larger schools, coaching staffs are often bigger, and interactions may be more structured or formal. While you may work with specialists (fitness, video, technical), it’s important to be proactive and professional in your communication.

If standing out and showing leadership is part of your plan, read How to Impress College Coaches at Showcases and Tournaments.

Exposure and Recruiting Potential

It’s true that Division I programs often offer more visibility, especially for players aiming to turn pro. Scouts from MLS, USL, and international clubs frequently attend D1 games and showcases.

However, players at small colleges also go pro—especially if they stand out, build a strong highlight video, or compete in summer leagues like USL League Two. Success isn’t exclusive to one level.

What matters most is your development, playing time, and drive—not just the badge on your jersey.

Time Commitment and Lifestyle

At big programs, soccer is almost like a full-time job. Players often have morning lifts, midday classes, afternoon practices, recovery sessions, and team meetings. Travel for games can mean days away from campus.

At smaller colleges, schedules may be more flexible, with fewer travel demands and more balance between athletics and personal life. This can be ideal for athletes who want a strong soccer experience while pursuing internships, part-time jobs, or academic research.

That balance also plays into your well-being. If you want to learn how to manage stress and stay mentally sharp as a student-athlete, don’t miss our blog on The Role of Mental Health in College Soccer.

Final Thoughts

There’s no “better” or “worse” when comparing small schools and big universities—it all comes down to what fits you.

If you're looking for top-level competition, elite facilities, and high exposure, a larger program might be the right path. If you value personal connections, a balanced lifestyle, and strong academics, a smaller college could be the perfect environment to grow.

In both settings, success comes from your work ethic, attitude, and ability to adapt. Choose the path that aligns with your goals, and make the most of every opportunity on and off the field.